“New Atheists” Find A Threat Even Bigger Than God

By Senior Religion Correspondent: Eli Bronstein

After claiming victory in the war of science vs. religion, “New Atheists,” Richard Dawkins, (The God Delusion), Christopher Hitchens (God Is Not Great) and Sam Harris (The End Of Faith), now turn their embattled sights to an even more sinister enemy: poetry. With their cool, calm and dispassionate reasoning, these level headed rationalists have managed to shake the albatross of superstition and childish faith from the neck of humanity – but is their job really done?

When asked about this new crusade Harris said, “Sure we’ve managed to get rid of a lot Bibles, but metaphors are everywhere! Metaphors are like air. …shit!”

Dawkins takes an even stronger stand: “Poems are useless. Just look at Shakespeare, ‘Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?’ Why would you compare a person to a measurement of time? Or to a demarcation of  the earth’s orbit in relation to the sun? A person is not a day, summer or any other season.  It’s amazing how much smarter I am than everyone else in the world.” He added, “If you want some inspirational reading, try the periodic table of the elements. I’ve never been able to finish it without crying.”

When asked if he might concede that there are those who don’t take poetic writing literally, and do not want to replace Albert Einstein with Walt Whitman, Hitchens insisted it is tantamount to enabling those who might: “First you’re saying ‘her heart is like a rose.’ Then, ‘her smile is like sunlight.’ Pretty soon you’re not sure what anything really is and you’re eating your own shoes and smearing toothpaste in your hair.”

Though some might say that these very successful pop writers are merely pointing out the painfully obvious and throwing out the baby with the proverbial bathwater, all three take issue with this position, saying a baby would never fit through a drain pipe.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to “New Atheists” Find A Threat Even Bigger Than God

  1. This is fantastic. My laughter upon reading was like thunder.

    • eliotjames says:

      Thanks Keith. I was wondering who I was writing this for, other than myself. Glad to you know you’re one of those people.

  2. Franklin says:

    I hate where this is going, but I love that you wrote it.

    • eliotjames says:

      ummmm, thanks??

      • Franklin says:

        The thing I hate is that these writers have basically created a new religion without really trying. As such they’re now saying that their bottom line beliefs are the only ones acceptable and anything else is in error. If you want a great example of someone who uses extreme rationality to justify his position, think Dick Cheney. There is a reason he’s had so many heart problems. These guys are no different. Their leap of faith is in believing that reason alone is the only means of knowing what is true, which I believe is categorically not true. Reason is only a small piece of consciousness, and it’s a somewhat unimportant one.

        I know that you were writing a funny piece here. That I can appreciate. It is another great example of how humor can be used to see a clearer picture of the truth, and that’s something I’ve always loved about your writing…songs and otherwise.

        • eliotjames says:

          Good points Franklin, but faith cannot “leap.” That’s for frogs and years. Wait wait, not years. Damn this is hard!

  3. someone says:


  4. Gilda Sue says:

    I know exactly what those boys are up to. But my whole life is a metaphor. Or is it more like a simile? Whatever– believe it or not, it rocks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s